General Categories > Information Arsenal
Hey, Special Snowflake!
JTH:
--- Quote from: depserv on February 09, 2015, 08:32:17 AM ---But the article ignores the fact that a lot of people have had life and death experiences, that involve what it calls an adrenaline dump and having to stay calm and do their best, so they might know more about how they will perform than we think. For example, years ago one of my neighbors tried to commit suicide by hanging himself; his mother came up to his room and saw him hanging; she stayed very calm, cut him down, and called 911. She didn't panic and she saved his life. How many of us have had something happen suddenly when we were driving and had to react suddenly and do everything just right to avoid a crash, and found that we stayed calm and did everything right? I had a scaffold suddenly drop out from under me quite a few years ago when I was about 60 feet up; I caught myself, stayed very calm, and climbed back to the part that didn't collapse; I remember looking back and noticing the difficulty in the climb I had made and thinking at the time how it seemed like the easiest thing in the world. It scared the hell out of the other guys on the scaffold that didn't fall, but the one whose life was on the line didn't get scared. How many of us have had experiences like that? I think they give us an idea of how we'll do under stress in a life or death situation.
--- End quote ---
Stress in a life or death situation, yes---but that isn't the same as a self-defense situation. For example, I know a couple of people (medical folks) who are calm and collected in a crisis. In emergency situations in which people's lives were literally in their hands, they remained level-headed and rational.
Those same people, in a simple straightforward scenario, when faced with incipient direct violence, lost it and completely froze up.
This isn't to say that all medical people will lose it. Or that all people who demonstrate a cool head under stress WON'T keep that under direct threat of violence. Or that all people overall will lose it in those circumstances.
My point is simply that if you haven't dealt or practiced with direct violent threats, you don't know how you will handle it--because other types of stressors aren't the same.
It is like the people who suggest sprinting 50 yards then doing 20 fast pushups prior to shooting for stress training--the argument is that doing those exercises gives you the shakes and gets your heart rate up, the same as what happens during an adrenaline dump, so training that way is as good as scenario training.
But it isn't. That's not to say don't do that training, because anything that stresses you and tries to take your mind away from what is important will be useful practice, if done well.
But it is still NOT the same in terms of stress reactions. And there is a big difference between having a cool head in an impersonal crisis and having to verbally interact with a belligerent person who is potentially escalating to a direct physical altercation while you attempt to decide how to keep yourself safe.
If you haven't done it, you don't know.
Many people claim they know how they are going to react. But if they've never even done a single scenario, how could they know?
--- Quote ---Competition, on the other hand, is stressful, but it is not life or death.
--- End quote ---
Don't believe I claimed it was. The stress aspect is good, but I did specifically mention that the competition aspect is more for rating your technical abilities.
--- Quote ---I don't point this out to suggest that training is not a good thing; I say do all you can, and use competition to make the training as realistic as you can.
--- End quote ---
Personally, I don't consider any form of shooting competition I've seen to be even remotely realistic training for self-defense. I find them useful for all sorts of things---but realism is not one of them.
I realize that IDPA claims to be realistic, but that's really nonsense. When "turn around and walk away" isn't a viable choice, when no verbal interaction or choice-making is possible, and when moving into threats as fast as possible is the best way to win--it isn't realistic.
Don't get me wrong---I love competition shooting. I think it is a great test of shooting skills, and I STRONGLY suggest everyone try it at least once.
But it isn't self-defense training. IMO.
--- Quote ---But it seems like the concealed carry community is constantly telling us how we're going to be so scared we'll barely be able to move. Saying that gives a person the look of one with wisdom on the subject, so everyone wants to outdo each other about how scared we'll be. I'm not a psychologist, but I think this might have the effect of parents constantly telling their kids that they're stupid or bad or won't ever amount to anything. It's fine to let people know what to expect, but I think it's overdone sometimes. This article didn't overdo it, but other things I've seen did.
--- End quote ---
There is a lot of that out there, isn't there? (I'm glad you think I didn't do that.)
A lot of that is bad information where we know better now--but people still trot out the "if your heart goes over 160 you won't be able to think or reason" and other nonsense. In some ways, it is similar to the "OMG! Common substance X causes cancer!" media blurbs we hear, in which factual research is misunderstood and shock/scare blurbs are created that don't actually mean anything, and that people parrot without understanding.
JTH:
--- Quote from: Lmbass14 on February 09, 2015, 09:56:56 AM ---Yep, I can shoot a quarter at 600 yards with my glock 23 open sights. Of course those are head shots. I'm the best. I know it all.
--- End quote ---
You have my attention, and I'd like to take your class, sir.
:)
--- Quote ---Until you go to a Rock your Glock or any other competition and get your a$$ handed to you on a platter.
--- End quote ---
It's quite a shock for many people---and many walk away and never come back. They can't take the ego hit that happens.
--- Quote ---Need to go to the ENGC and shoot one of those plate mates. And I know it will be another reality check. Also will also bet that something will be learn which I would become a better shooter.
--- End quote ---
This coming Sunday, Steel Challenge match! Probably the most useful match type in terms of testing the most important self-defense shooting skills, because it is all about drawing and getting accurate fast hits.
And it is a ton of fun. :)
abbafandr:
--- Quote from: jthhapkido on February 09, 2015, 12:54:41 PM ---I realize that IDPA claims to be realistic, but that's really nonsense. When "turn around and walk away" isn't a viable choice, when no verbal interaction or choice-making is possible, and when moving into threats as fast as possible is the best way to win--it isn't realistic.
--- End quote ---
Have to agree with you there. IDPA is just a different competition with it's own set of rules. But I still enjoy playing the game. Can't touch USPSA matches though IMO.
David Hineline:
I have one Sensai do not disrespect him.
JTH:
--- Quote from: David Hineline on February 15, 2015, 11:21:40 PM ---I have one Sensai do not disrespect him.
--- End quote ---
Awhile back Lorimor posted some videos of that guy, and they were so train-wreck-fascinating that I had to look him up more.
It's got to be the best thing in the world to be that divorced from reality. Where his mind is, he's just about the most amazing person on the planet. Deadly, adventurous, strong, smart, prepared, helping others all the time---given who he thinks he is and what he thinks he has done, he's got to be the happiest person on the planet.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version