bullit, your statement about personal umbrella policies covering you for lethal force is not entirely accurate, although Allied?s Umbrella give the most generous language I have been able to find. Not all Umbrella Policies are created equal. Also Allied doesn?t offer any Uninsured/Underinsured coverage through their umbrella yet even though they need to because other carries already do. You have a good policy, plus your thinking in the right direction.
Guys this is where you got to make your agent show it to you in writing. Yes, Excess Liability or Umbrella policy are a good thing to have and everyone should have one, as bullit stated above. Some free advice is to go to the exclusion part of your Umbrella policy. The problem arises out of the "Intended and Expected (sometimes unexpected) ? acts that cause bodily injury and property damage (see your definitions for BI) are excluded. Now some policy have some sort of what is called give backs, meaning they take it away but give it back later in the policy. I have seen some companies only give back for reasonable assault or battery acts to protect one's person or property(P&P). I have seen reasonable acts to protect one's P&P. And yes bullit, Allied uses the best terminology I have found because theirs say reasonable force to protect one's P&P. And it seems LE always talk in terms of force continuums.
Now that said I seriously doubt anyone will have a judgment go against them, but it is the attorney fees that is the scariest. Sad thing is that allot of these home invasions are done by rich kids. Myself personally I will try to find the best attorney possible but I could see myself wiping out my saving and a 2nd mortgage just to make sure I am able to tuck my kids in every night. Because I am trying fend off Mommy/Daddy Mega-bucks civil suit. Even though the Umbrella policy may pay for judgments doesn?t mean they will pay for defense, because they know there is almost a zero chance you would loose other wise they would settle through arbitration. Lets face it insurance companies are not going to spend money if they feel they need to and if you have a true righteous shooting you will not loose in civil court. Some companies writing (you will find it at the front of your policy) say it is at their discretion to step in.