There is a spring and ball bearing in the rear sight that gives it that wobble that you probably at first thought was wrong. It automatically cants it so that does not sit square on the carry handle. Without being able to see the picture you posted it is hard to tell. But if the elevation and windage moved freely it was probably normal. Are you sure when you put the original sight back on you got the spring and the ball bearings in there correctly. They are very small and can be a pain in the arse.